Selection Criteria
Minimum requirements that suppliers must meet to be considered for a contract, covering financial standing, technical capacity, and professional qualifications. Distinct from award criteria.
In Detail
Selection criteria are the minimum qualification requirements that suppliers must satisfy to be considered eligible for participation in a procurement procedure. Governed by Articles 58-64 of Directive 2014/24/EU, selection criteria assess the supplier's ability to perform the contract rather than the quality or value of their tender. They are structured around three pillars: suitability to pursue the professional activity (e.g., trade register enrollment, professional certifications), economic and financial standing (e.g., minimum annual turnover, adequate insurance, positive financial ratios), and technical and professional ability (e.g., relevant past contract references, qualified staff, equipment, quality management systems).
The EU Directives impose important constraints on selection criteria to ensure proportionality and prevent barriers to competition. For example, a contracting authority cannot require annual turnover exceeding twice the estimated contract value except in duly justified cases. The number of past references requested must be proportionate, and authorities should accept references from the last three to five years. These rules are designed to prevent authorities from setting unnecessarily high barriers that would exclude capable suppliers — particularly SMEs — from competing.
Selection criteria operate on a pass/fail basis: a supplier either meets the minimum requirements or does not. They are applied before award criteria and serve as a gateway to the evaluation process. In an open procedure, selection and award criteria are assessed on all submitted tenders (though selection criteria are checked first). In a restricted procedure, selection criteria are used to pre-qualify and shortlist candidates before the tender stage. The distinction between selection criteria and award criteria is fundamental — conflating the two (for example, giving higher scores for more experience rather than treating experience as a threshold requirement) is a common error that can invalidate a procurement.
Practical Context
How it works in practice
For suppliers, understanding the selection criteria is essential for making a bid/no-bid decision. If a company does not meet the minimum financial standing or reference requirements, there is no point in investing time in a tender response. Experienced bid teams assess selection criteria compliance as the first step in their tender review process. On TenderRadar, selection criteria are extracted from published notices and displayed alongside award criteria, enabling users to quickly filter opportunities where they meet the qualification thresholds. Suppliers with limited procurement experience often focus on building their reference portfolio through smaller contracts before pursuing tenders with demanding selection criteria.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a supplier use subcontractor experience to meet selection criteria?
Yes, under Article 63 of Directive 2014/24/EU, suppliers can rely on the capacities of other entities (including subcontractors, consortium partners, or parent companies) to meet selection criteria, provided they can demonstrate that they will actually have access to those capacities for the contract. The supporting entity may need to provide its own ESPD and evidence.
What is the maximum turnover requirement a contracting authority can set?
The Directive limits the minimum annual turnover requirement to a maximum of twice the estimated contract value, except in duly justified cases where a higher threshold is necessary due to special risks associated with the nature of the contract. This rule is designed to ensure proportionality and prevent unnecessary barriers to SME participation.
Are selection criteria the same across all EU countries?
The framework for selection criteria is harmonized through the EU Directives, but the specific requirements set by individual contracting authorities vary by contract. National transposition may add additional rules or guidance. The types of evidence accepted (certificates, registers, financial statements) also vary by member state due to different national administrative systems.
Related Terms
Explore related concepts
Put this knowledge into action
Find government tenders matched to your business with AI.